I will beta read fantasy, romance beta reader, cozy mystery, alpha beta reader
Gig Summary
Your book from a pro developmental editor's lens
Level 1
Has met certain performance criteria and shows strong potential in the marketplace.
Highly Responsive
Known for exceptionally quick replies
What people loved about this freelancer
eyzerep25

United States
Madeline provided me a front row seat to the readers prospective in detailed online comments in a document. I enjoyed hearing her opinions and reactions. Great...
richard_math

United States
She read my entire book in just a few days and delivered an incredibly thorough, detailed report. I really appreciated that her feedback felt genuine and thoughtful,...
jadellheim

United States
Madeline Jack is amazing! She did such a quick turnaround on my contemporary romance manuscript, but didn’t skip a single beat. Her report was incredibly detailed...
carriepalafox

United States
Madeline Jack is amazing! I love that she analyzes each chapter and provides an individual report rather than one full manuscript report. This approach helps...
andreaeichel

Germany
Wow! working with this beta reader has been an absolute game-changer for my manuscript. It was so in-depth, honest, insightful, and thorough. I will definitely use her for my coming drafts. I highly recommend.
About this Gig
Wondering if your plot is engaging, your characters feel authentic, or your pacing keeps readers hooked?
Your story deserves more than a quick read. It deserves thoughtful, in-depth feedback from someone who reads like your future audience.
As an experienced beta reader and manuscript reviewer, I offer a comprehensive and professional critique of your work, ensuring it resonates with your target audience. Whether you're working on fantasy, romance, sci-fi, horror, thriller, contemporary romance, or general fiction, I provide detailed feedback on plot structure, pacing, character development, and more, helping you refine your novel for maximum impact.
What I Offer
As your beta/alpha reader, I focus on the reader experience while also providing deeper critique when needed.
You'll receive feedback on:
- Plot structure & pacing
- Character development & consistency
- Dialogue realism
- World-building (especially for fantasy)
- Emotional impact (key for romance)
- Tension, suspense, and stakes (for thriller/horror)
- Clarity, flow, and readability
- Overall engagement and market readiness
Ready to take your book to the next level? Get in touch, and let's make your manuscript shine.
Language:
English
Delivery style preference
Please inform the freelancer of any preferences or concerns regarding the use of AI tools in the completion and/or delivery of your order.
My Portfolio
FAQ
What kind of feedback will I receive?
You’ll receive honest and detailed, reader-focused feedback on pacing, characters, plot flow, dialogue, emotional impact, and overall engagement. I explain what’s working well and where the story may need stronger development.
Do you edit grammar and spelling?
Yes, I do have experience with proofreading and editing, and I naturally notice grammar, wording, and readability issues while reading. However, this gig is centered on beta reading and manuscript critique rather than full line editing or proofreading.
What genres do you specialise in?
I specialize in thrillers, horror, cozy mystery, romance, and romantasy. I’m especially drawn to stories with strong atmosphere, emotional tension, suspense, and compelling character dynamics.
Will you be honest if something in the manuscript doesn’t work?
Yes. My feedback is constructive but truthful. I won’t give vague praise or overlook weak areas. If something feels confusing, slow, repetitive, or emotionally flat, I’ll explain why from a reader’s perspective
Do you offer inline comments throughout the manuscript?
Yes. Inline comments are available as a separate add-on for writers who want detailed reactions and notes directly inside the manuscript while I read. This includes scene-by-scene thoughts, emotional reactions, and specific observations.
29 reviews for this Gig
| (28) | ||
| (1) | ||
| (0) | ||
| (0) | ||
| (0) |
Rating Breakdown
- Seller communication level
- Quality of delivery
- Value of delivery
Sort By
E 
eyzerep25

United States
Madeline provided me a front row seat to the readers prospective in detailed online comments in a document. I enjoyed hearing her opinions and reactions. Great actionable steps that made sense were also provided. Great understanding of the work itself.
$50-$100
Price
2 days
Duration
M 
Seller's Response
Helpful?R richard_math

United States
She read my entire book in just a few days and delivered an incredibly thorough, detailed report. I really appreciated that her feedback felt genuine and thoughtful, with no AI-generated responses. She caught several small details and clues that I honestly didn’t expect a reader to notice! My main goal...
$50
Price
4 days
Duration
M 
Seller's Response
Helpful?J 
jadellheim

United States
Ongoing collaborationMadeline Jack is amazing! She did such a quick turnaround on my contemporary romance manuscript, but didn’t skip a single beat. Her report was incredibly detailed and packed with awesome insights and super helpful suggestions for the story. She really understood the vibe and characters perfectly. If...
$50
Price
5 days
Duration
M 
Seller's Response
Helpful?C carriepalafox

United States
Ongoing collaborationMadeline Jack is amazing! I love that she analyzes each chapter and provides an individual report rather than one full manuscript report. This approach helps me better understand her feedback and work through revisions one chapter at a time. She has a wonderful eye for detail, and I truly appreciate her thoroughness!
$50-$100
Price
5 days
Duration
Helpful?A andreaeichel

Germany
Wow! working with this beta reader has been an absolute game-changer for my manuscript. It was so in-depth, honest, insightful, and thorough. I will definitely use her for my coming drafts. I highly recommend.
$50
Price
4 days
Duration
M 
Seller's Response
Helpful?
29 reviews for this Gig
| (28) | ||
| (1) | ||
| (0) | ||
| (0) | ||
| (0) |
Rating Breakdown
- Seller communication level
- Quality of delivery
- Value of delivery
Sort By
E 
eyzerep25

United States
Madeline provided me a front row seat to the readers prospective in detailed online comments in a document. I enjoyed hearing her opinions and reactions. Great actionable steps that made sense were also provided. Great understanding of the work itself.
$50-$100
Price
2 days
Duration
M 
Seller's Response
Helpful?R richard_math

United States
She read my entire book in just a few days and delivered an incredibly thorough, detailed report. I really appreciated that her feedback felt genuine and thoughtful, with no AI-generated responses. She caught several small details and clues that I honestly didn’t expect a reader to notice! My main goal...
$50
Price
4 days
Duration
M 
Seller's Response
Helpful?J 
jadellheim

United States
Ongoing collaborationMadeline Jack is amazing! She did such a quick turnaround on my contemporary romance manuscript, but didn’t skip a single beat. Her report was incredibly detailed and packed with awesome insights and super helpful suggestions for the story. She really understood the vibe and characters perfectly. If...
$50
Price
5 days
Duration
M 
Seller's Response
Helpful?C carriepalafox

United States
Ongoing collaborationMadeline Jack is amazing! I love that she analyzes each chapter and provides an individual report rather than one full manuscript report. This approach helps me better understand her feedback and work through revisions one chapter at a time. She has a wonderful eye for detail, and I truly appreciate her thoroughness!
$50-$100
Price
5 days
Duration
Helpful?A andreaeichel

Germany
Wow! working with this beta reader has been an absolute game-changer for my manuscript. It was so in-depth, honest, insightful, and thorough. I will definitely use her for my coming drafts. I highly recommend.
$50
Price
4 days
Duration
M 
Seller's Response
Helpful?

