I will beta read your book and provide thoughtful feedback without ai

4.9
4.9

Italy

I speak English

464 orders completed

American writer living in Italy

Hi there! I’m Nathaniel. I’m a full time writer and editor. As a writer, I understand the struggle and difficulty that can come with writing a novel and I’m happy to help alleviate some of yours! Wh...

Top Rated

Top Rated sellers are individually selected by Fiverr after meeting specific benchmarks for quality and service.

What people loved about this freelancer

About this Gig

No AI is used by me at any point of this process.


Please send me a message before ordering so I can create a custom order tailored to your needs!


Just finished your manuscript and need someone to look it over? I'd be happy to do so!


I read fantasy, science fiction, romance, mystery, young adult, general fiction, memoirs, travelogues, and so much more!


I will read through your manuscript and offer thoughtful, honest, and critical advice and feedback about pacing, clarity, structure, characters and character development, and general content. Where applicable, I will also add inline comments. These aren't play-by-play thoughts of your story, but will be used where something minor might need correcting or clarifying.


My Reader Report will vary in length (usually around 7-15 pages) and typically includes a brief section of the story's strengths, and a longer section with my recommendations.


I usually read in Microsoft Word or Pages but I don't mind reading other forms like PDFs.


I look forward to reading your work!


If you also need your manuscript edited, I offer a 10% discount on my editing service if I've beta read your manuscript.

Genre:

Literary fiction

Language:

English

Delivery style preference

Please inform the freelancer of any preferences or concerns regarding the use of AI tools in the completion and/or delivery of your order.

My Portfolio

Reviews

233 reviews for this Gig
4.9

(221)
(11)
(0)
(1)
(0)
Rating Breakdown
  • Seller communication level
    4.9
  • Quality of delivery
    4.9
  • Value of delivery
    4.9
Sort By
Most relevant
  • A
    image-docs

    abacc15

    US

    United States

    5

    I booked Nathaniel's gig to beta read my book in the hopes that I would receive a few solid ideas or pointers on how to improve my story. I ended up receiving a 9 page document that went into a lot of great detail about my story's strengths and weaknesses, possible opportunities for improvement, and...

    $200-$400

    Price

    3 weeks

    Duration

    Helpful?
    Yes
    No
  • P
    image-docs

    patremblayautho

    US

    United States

    5

    Not only did Nathaniel deliver on time, but he delivered a beta reader review that was by far the most detailed and actionable review I’ve ever received, and that includes reviews by professional editors. He showed that he truly understood the story, and every single recommendation he gave me was spot...

    $200-$400

    Price

    2 weeks

    Duration

    Helpful?
    Yes
    No
  • C
    image-docs

    chantal_de_kock

    ZA

    South Africa

    5

    Nathaniel is a great beta reader. His report was thoughtful and detailed, and it was clear that he engaged carefully with the manuscript. He helped confirm that the revised opening structure was working and that the reductions in word count had not made the story feel condensed or incomplete. He also...

    $50-$100

    Price

    5 days

    Duration

    Helpful?
    Yes
    No
  • C
    image-docs

    c_king_create

    US

    United States

    5

    Nathaniel's feedback was insightful, encouraging, and incisive. I hired another Beta reader, who was good, but Nathaniel went beyond. I felt that not only had he read my work carefully, but considered broad implications of the work, where it might go, and what could bring it to the next level. I will definitely be hiring him again for similar projects.

    $100-$200

    Price

    2 weeks

    Duration

    Helpful?
    Yes
    No
  • L

    linhcnguyen

    US

    United States

    4.3

    Nathaniel points out problems no other beta reader had spotted. He's attentive and good at explaining the reader's view point to help your manuscript connects as best as possible with your reader. He's also delivers fast. Would love to work with Nathaniel again.

    $200-$400

    Price

    3 weeks

    Duration

    Helpful?
    Yes
    No
Reviews

233 reviews for this Gig
4.9

(221)
(11)
(0)
(1)
(0)
Rating Breakdown
  • Seller communication level
    4.9
  • Quality of delivery
    4.9
  • Value of delivery
    4.9
Sort By
Most relevant
  • A
    image-docs

    abacc15

    US

    United States

    5

    I booked Nathaniel's gig to beta read my book in the hopes that I would receive a few solid ideas or pointers on how to improve my story. I ended up receiving a 9 page document that went into a lot of great detail about my story's strengths and weaknesses, possible opportunities for improvement, and...

    $200-$400

    Price

    3 weeks

    Duration

    Helpful?
    Yes
    No
  • P
    image-docs

    patremblayautho

    US

    United States

    5

    Not only did Nathaniel deliver on time, but he delivered a beta reader review that was by far the most detailed and actionable review I’ve ever received, and that includes reviews by professional editors. He showed that he truly understood the story, and every single recommendation he gave me was spot...

    $200-$400

    Price

    2 weeks

    Duration

    Helpful?
    Yes
    No
  • C
    image-docs

    chantal_de_kock

    ZA

    South Africa

    5

    Nathaniel is a great beta reader. His report was thoughtful and detailed, and it was clear that he engaged carefully with the manuscript. He helped confirm that the revised opening structure was working and that the reductions in word count had not made the story feel condensed or incomplete. He also...

    $50-$100

    Price

    5 days

    Duration

    Helpful?
    Yes
    No
  • C
    image-docs

    c_king_create

    US

    United States

    5

    Nathaniel's feedback was insightful, encouraging, and incisive. I hired another Beta reader, who was good, but Nathaniel went beyond. I felt that not only had he read my work carefully, but considered broad implications of the work, where it might go, and what could bring it to the next level. I will definitely be hiring him again for similar projects.

    $100-$200

    Price

    2 weeks

    Duration

    Helpful?
    Yes
    No
  • L

    linhcnguyen

    US

    United States

    4.3

    Nathaniel points out problems no other beta reader had spotted. He's attentive and good at explaining the reader's view point to help your manuscript connects as best as possible with your reader. He's also delivers fast. Would love to work with Nathaniel again.

    $200-$400

    Price

    3 weeks

    Duration

    Helpful?
    Yes
    No